I
don’t know wtf is going on with media messaging in the world where my third
grade daughter is worried that she’s fat.
I’ve
tried responses that concentrate on what our bodies can do (can I run? Can I
swim? Can i climb the monkey bars? Can i play tennis with my friends? And
karate too? Yay! I’m healthy!) and how our doctor says she is perfectly healthy
every year at her physical. That honestly our DOCTOR is the person who can tell
us if there’s an issue about weight, and no one else. She’ll agree for a few
days but then it’s like she doesn’t hear it at all, she comes home saying my
belly is fat or my belly is big. That this girl or that girl at school says her
belly is fat (as in talking about herself, not my daughter’s; it’s the self
loathing talk that’s bumming me out—and i know these girls they are little
growing toothpicks).
I’ve
tried to normalize that bellies are just bellies and bending over makes our
bellies look different, to no avail. I’ve monitored the way I speak about my
body around her to make sure I’m not passing along negative body imaging to
her. I say I exercise so I can be healthy and live a long life (not that I’m
trying to lose weight or trying to be skinny, and that’s fine if those are
personal goals out there in the world, just not trying to put those world’s expectations
on her). Urggggg.
So
in the moment, I resorted to: I can’t stop you from saying negative things
about yourself DD2, even though I know the words aren’t true. I need you to say
some different words for yourself though. So from now on, any time you say
something negative, like my belly is fat, I want you to say something positive,
too. Like, I can read chapter books. I can swim all afternoon. She half
heartedly repeated these words. And was like
awwww,
do I have to?
And
I was like: if I catch you saying negative things about yourself without saying
something positive, no playing games on the IPAD.
Her
(eyes as big at saucers): For how long?
Me:
FOREVER.
Her:
OKAY MOMMY.
...
FFS
I
recalled going through this a little bit with DD1, but not to the constant
repeat loop that seems to be with DD2.
And, she still bounces around and plays with her friends, like today she
swam for two hours straight in the pool, just venting about the negative body
talk that she’s taken on. Is it parroting? Does she really think this? Probably
a bit of both. And IPAD threatening was
not my best moment, but I fail all the time so just add it to the tally of shit
I do wrong. Tomorrow is another damn
day.
------
Day
2: So after a somewhat good night's sleep, I felt a little better about this
being a marathon type of conversation/issue and not a here's a few steps to
solve the challenge type of situation.
So okay, life, I'll take this challenge, dang it. One of the silver linings out of the
conversations of late is this: she
actually talks to me about it. she feels
safe enough with me to tell me her worries and fears, so I need to be less
judgmental about her worries and fears and more supportive of how to be a
positive force in her life. I'll keep up
with positive talk and will lesson the IPAD threats, and understand that if we
still struggle with messaging as a 20, 30, 40
year olds (my goal is that by 50 i just wont gaf, i'm pretty close to
IDGAF, but i've been conditioned by the same media messaging), then of course
this is going to seep into an 8 year old's realm, whether i like it or
not. p.s. she brought it up again this
morning when i was braiding her hair.
she was hesitant to say the word 'fat,' i think in part because she
didn't want me to harsh on feminist theory at 6am? LOL.
so i said, honey, i realize you have your thoughts and feelings about
this, and the world is going to say one thing, and we have to say other things
back. so what would you like to say
back? i can swim? she said yes.
i can read all the books? she
said yes. and i said, anything
else? and she said: i can run. ❤
And…my
heart melted.
Lastly,
an extra:
Gillette
embraced the Be the Best a Man can Be to mean more than brawny, uninformed
masculinity, and I actually teared up.
Of course there’s backlash from the trolls and threats to boycott, which
means it struck a nerve. You can see it here.
I
know, I know, I teared up at a SHAVING commercial. But I teared up because this mainstream,
commercial (usually money-grubbing and not giving a f!@$) world has embraced the
idea of a BETTER way to be. I imagined
how different my experiences would have been if I had grown up in this one, and
maybe that’s why I teared up. A hope
that the world can be better.
Because
world, I **need** you to be a better place for my two little girls who are
growing up fast.
๐๐๐ It’s wonderful that she can share her feelings with you, and feel safe. I can’t imagine what it’s like to be doing this work, but I’m sure you’ll help as much as possible.
ReplyDeleteI teared up at that ad, too. I’m just glad we’re finally, slowly making a little progress.
<3 <3 <3 hugs and love to you, jessica!!! <3 I'm glad to hear I'm not the only one who teared up, lol. here's to slowly, slowly making progress... !!!! :D
DeleteAwww, my heart goes out to DD2. It seems so young to have these concerns but then, I recall becoming so insecure at a young age (my brother told me I was getting fat). One of the natural parts of early adolescence is putting on a little bit extra pounds before they actually show pubescent bodies. So, it's all natural if she's gaining a bit of weight. It's part of the human growth.
ReplyDeleteYou've handled this perfectly, Jane.
I watched the Gillette ad. What a breakthrough!! I noticed, however, that there were 3X the thumbs down as the thumbs up. Can't say I've ever seen that before in the likes section of a youtube video. Trolls, indeed.
Great post and we were thinking along the same lines today :P
Thanks for stopping by, Lisa!!! <3 I feel your young age self; I was also struggling with body image issues. I guess I shouldn't be surprised that my DDs are going through them too... as a parent, i just want the world to be better for her, dang it!!! Love and hugs to you!!
Delete